Talk
Beyond Univariate Calibration: Verification of Spatial Structure in Ensembles of Forecast Fields
Talk by Josh Jacobson
Speaker invited by: Prof. Dr. Reinhard Furrer
Date: 26.11.19 Time: 17.00 - 17.45 Room:
Abstract:
Most available verification metrics for ensemble forecasts focus on univariate quantities. That is, they assess whether the ensemble provides an adequate representation of the forecast uncertainty about the quantity of interest at a particular location and time. For spatially-indexed ensemble forecasts, however, it is also important that forecast fields reproduce the spatial structure of the observed field, and represent the uncertainty about spatial properties such as the size of the area for which heavy precipitation, high winds, critical fire weather conditions, etc. are expected. In this work, we study the properties of a new diagnostic tool designed for spatially-indexed ensemble forecast fields. The metric is based on a level-crossing statistic that we term the fraction of threshold exceedance (FTE), and is calculated for the verification field, and separately for each ensemble member. It yields a projection of a -- possibly high-dimensional -- multivariate quantity onto a univariate quantity that can be studied with standard tools like verification rank histograms. This projection is appealing since it reflects a spatial property that is intuitive and directly relevant in applications, but it is not obvious whether the FTE is sufficiently sensitive to misrepresentation of spatial structure in the ensemble. In a comprehensive simulation study we find that departures from uniformity of these so called FTE histograms can be indeed be related to forecast ensembles with biased spatial variability, and that these histograms detect shortcomings in the spatial structure of ensemble forecast fields that are not obvious by eye. For demonstration, FTE histograms are applied in the context of spatially downscaled ensemble precipitation forecast fields from NOAA's Global Ensemble Forecast System.